Friday, November 5, 2010

Navajo Nation Public Interest Groups Send Notice of Suit to NN President

Days after a closely-watched Navajo Nation election, where the first female presidential candidate, Lynda Lovejoy, narrowly lost to incumbent, Ben Shelly, the Forgotten People, a grassroots advocacy organization, issued this announcement:


Window Rock, October 30, 2010

Today Elouise Brown, the president of Dooda Desert Rock, and Don Yellowman, the president of  The Forgotten People, announced that they have given notice of suit to President Joe Shirley, Jr., Attorney General Louis Denetsosie, and whoever the acting Legislative Counsel may be, to address any attempt to interfere with the independence and integrity of the Navajo Nation court system.

“We take this opportunity to file a protective notice,” said Elouise Brown, “because we are being alerted of moves to remove the Chief Justice, change the Judiciary Committee procedures for removal hearings, and otherwise obstruct justice and the rule of law.”  Don Yellowman added: “It is about time that the powers that be understood that there is a separation of powers in the Navajo Nation and it means something.  The Navajo Nation judicial system secured the right of individuals such as me and Elouise to get into court, and the right of our grassroots organizations to be heard, so we felt we must act.”

The notice says that the plaintiffs intend to act on behalf of Navajos who want access to a fair and impartial court system, and attorney James W. Zion proposes to enter the suit on behalf of clients.  The notice states a broad range of claims designed to anticipate any attack on the judicial system, and it puts the Navajo Nation on notice that the plaintiffs will claim as much protection for the court system as the law allows.

Brown and Yellowman jointly noted that the Navajo Nation Bill of Rights guarantees an independent and fair court system as part of the due process right of access to the courts.  “No matter what the legislative lawyers say, the Council cannot abolish the court system,” they said, “and we give warning that we will not tolerate legislative interference in the functioning of the court system.” 

Below is the notice of suit: 

TO:                  The Honorable Joe Shirley, Jr., President of the Navajo Nation
                        Louis Denetsosie, Esq.,  Attorney General of the Navajo Nation
                        The Acting Legislative Counsel of the Navajo Nation

PLEASE TAKE NOTICE, pursuant to 1 N.N.C. § 555(A) (2005), that the within-named public interest organizations and individuals, on their own behalf and on behalf of a class consisting of members of the public who wish due process access to a fair and impartial judicial system and who are  beneficiaries of public properties and monies of the Navajo Nation, desire to institute suit against the Navajo Nation, certain of its officers and public officials, employees or agents, and notice is provided as follows:

Prospective Plaintiffs

The prospective plaintiffs are Dooda Desert Rock, a grassroots Navajo public interest organization;  Elouise Brown, a Navajo individual and president of Dooda Desert Rock; The Forgotten People, a grassroots Navajo public interest organization;  Don Yellowman, a Navajo individual and president of The Forgotten People; and James W. Zion, a member of the Navajo Nation Bar Association and lawyer for Navajo litigants in the Navajo Nation judicial system.  They sue as entities and individuals for themselves and members of the Navajo Nation public who wish access to a just and fair Navajo Nation judicial system and the protection of public properties and monies.

Prospective Defendants

The prospective defendants include the Navajo Nation, the Navajo Nation Council, Judiciary Committee,  Budget and Finance Committee, other committees of the Navajo Nation Council, the Controller of the Navajo Nation (for his management of Navajo Nation monies and funds), individuals in public office or acting under color of public office, and John and Jane Doe, being the fictitious names of other persons or entities whose identities and roles in this matter are as of yet unknown.

Nature of Claims

This action will be brought to protect the rights of all plaintiffs and the plaintiff class and to secure rights to due process of law by access to a judicial system that is just and fair; assure the separation of powers of Navajo Nation government for proper checks and balances;  take all actions necessary to prevent the removal of sitting justices or judges, the impeachment of sitting justices or judges, or any other adverse action against justices or judges, or judicial employees, including amendments to Judiciary Committee procedures not supported by the separation of powers;  assure the integrity of the judicial selection and evaluation process; and to protect the property and monies of the Navajo Nation by removing or impairing justices or judges as the guardians of such property and monies.  Claims will also be based on fundamental principles of good governance, the  naachid process, hazho’ogo, and The Fundamental Laws, including provisions on leadership, the judicial function and governance.  If, for any reason, actors attempt to improperly interfere with the plaintiffs or their counsel through the Navajo Nation Bar Association, action will be taken against it or its officers or employees.

Relief Sought

The plaintiffs will seek full relief to secure the above claims, including prospective injunctive relief, full equitable relief, mandamus, prohibition and nalyeeh to protect the judicial system and its justices and judges, as indicated.  The plaintiffs will seek appropriate relief to enjoin any act to change, amend, terminate personnel, or eliminate or modify funding, including inadequate funding, of the Judicial Branch of the Navajo Nation until such time as its future is secure under new legislative and executive leadership.  The plaintiffs will also seek their costs and attorney fees.

We'll see what comes of it. 

No comments:

Post a Comment